I’m often asked why a seller is choosing to sell their home. After 21 years of selling real estate on the Big Island, I’ve identified the top reasons sellers share with me about why they’re moving away from paradise. These reasons apply to both locals and transplants, in no particular order:
The High Cost of Living
Living in Hawaii can be expensive. Nearly everything—food, medicine, gas, power, and housing—comes with a premium because many goods are shipped from the mainland. Hawaii’s reliance on fossil fuels for power generation further drives up energy costs. Additionally, we have a general excise tax on services, including medical care, which adds to the financial burden.
Education
While Hawaii offers adequate public schools, they often don’t compare to the quality of education in many mainland states. Private school options are limited, especially on the outer islands, and the few available choices can be very expensive.
Medical Care
Hawaii provides solid healthcare facilities and services for most needs, but it lacks a sufficient number of physicians and specialists. New residents often struggle to find a primary care doctor, as many practices are full. For specialized care, travel to Oahu or even the mainland is often necessary.
Family Connections
Many who move here envision frequent visits from family back on the mainland, but reality doesn’t always match the dream. Over time, the distance can take its toll. Missing loved ones—children, grandchildren, or elderly parents—often prompts people to return to the mainland. Retirees, in particular, may relocate back to care for aging parents.
Business Challenges
Hawaii has a reputation for being one of the least business-friendly states in the U.S. Those who move here with entrepreneurial aspirations often face significant hurdles, including high costs, bureaucracy, and limited markets. Many eventually move back to states with more favorable business climates.
Job Opportunities
Job opportunities in Hawaii are limited, with most positions concentrated in service, construction, and retail. Young people who leave for college on the mainland often don’t return due to a lack of career options. Similarly, professionals who relocate to Hawaii sometimes struggle to find work in their field and decide to move back after a few years.
Island Fever
For some, island living can feel isolating. The inability to simply drive to another state or explore new cities can lead to a sense of confinement. Additionally, Hawaii’s consistent weather—while beautiful—lacks the seasonal variety many people enjoy, such as snowy winters or autumn leaves. Over time, this monotony can weigh on individuals who crave change or variety.
I must say, the majority of my past clients who have purchased homes here are very happy and content. They love island life, beaches, hiking and the serenity that Hawaii offers. Many are retirees and have no desire to move back to the state they came from. I too can honestly say I am not affected by any of the above and absolutely love living here, specifically the Big Island of Hawaii. I am fortunate to have a thriving career in real estate, and my husband works remotely as a telecom engineer. I do not get island fever and love the simple life. I am happy just spending a day at the beach or hiking the many beautiful trails we have. I have no desire to move back to the hustle and bustle of the mainland and can always visit if I want!
Vincent Saul
January 28, 2025
Anura and I are anticipating moving to the Big Island from Clovis, CA within the next 24-30 months.