Big Island

Buyer Representation Agreements in Hawaiʻi: What Buyers and Sellers Need to Know About the New Rules

If you have bought or sold real estate in the past, you may remember when buyers could simply call a Realtor, schedule appointments to view properties, and begin looking for their home without signing any paperwork.

That changed in August 2024, following a landmark nationwide settlement involving the National Association of REALTORS® (NAR).

Today, buyers working with a Realtor in Hawaiʻi are generally required to sign a written Buyer Representation Agreement before touring homes with that agent. For many buyers, this may seem like another unnecessary document. However, the purpose is to create greater transparency about the relationship between buyers and their agents, the services being provided, and how the buyer’s Realtor will be compensated.

working with a realtor to buy a home in hawaii

What Is a Buyer Representation Agreement?

A Buyer Representation Agreement is a written contract between a prospective homebuyer and a licensed real estate brokerage.

The agreement establishes the working relationship between the buyer and the brokerage and typically outlines:

  • The services the Realtor will provide.
  • The responsibilities of both the buyer and the brokerage.
  • The duration of the agreement.
  • Whether the representation is exclusive or nonexclusive.
  • How much the buyer’s brokerage will be compensated.
  • Whether the agreement applies to specific properties or a broader property search.

One important point: Signing a Buyer Representation Agreement does not automatically mean the buyer must pay the Realtor’s commission out of pocket.

The agreement establishes the compensation arrangement between the buyer and the brokerage. How that compensation is ultimately paid can be addressed through negotiations in the real estate transaction.

Why Did These Agreements Become Necessary?

In March 2024, the National Association of REALTORS® announced a proposed settlement resolving certain nationwide litigation involving real estate commissions. The resulting practice changes took effect on August 17, 2024. Previously, listing brokerages commonly advertised offers of compensation to buyer brokerages through the Multiple Listing Service (MLS). Under the new rules, offers of buyer-broker compensation are no longer permitted on the MLS. Additionally, MLS participants working with buyers must enter into written agreements before touring homes with those buyers, subject to the applicable rules and exceptions. These changes were intended to increase transparency and give consumers a clearer understanding of how their agents are compensated.

An important distinction: The requirement stems primarily from the NAR settlement and associated MLS practice rules, not from a new federal law requiring every homebuyer in the United States to sign a Buyer Representation Agreement.

Buying a home in hawaii with a realtor

Are Real Estate Commissions Negotiable?

Absolutely! In fact, real estate commissions have always been negotiable. There is no federally mandated commission rate, no Hawaiʻi state-mandated commission rate, and no standard percentage that all Realtors must charge. Under the new rules, compensation must be clearly addressed in the Buyer Representation Agreement. For example, a buyer and their Realtor might agree that the buyer’s brokerage will receive 2.5% of the purchase price. That percentage is negotiated between the buyer and their brokerage when they enter into their agreement. It is not automatically established by the listing agent, seller, or MLS. The amount must be objectively ascertainable and cannot be open-ended. A buyer’s brokerage also cannot receive compensation exceeding the amount agreed to in the Buyer Representation Agreement.

Understanding the Two Separate Commission Negotiations

The Buyer Representation Agreement establishes the compensation between the buyer and their brokerage. The Purchase Contract allows buyers and sellers to negotiate whether the seller will contribute toward that compensation.

The Buyer Representation Agreement and the HAR Purchase Contract serve two different purposes.

The Buyer Representation Agreement establishes the compensation arrangement between the buyer and their brokerage/agent. The Hawaiʻi Association of REALTORS® Purchase Contract allows the buyer and seller to negotiate whether the seller will contribute toward that compensation as part of the transaction. These are separate negotiations involving different parties.

How Does the Hawaiʻi Association of REALTORS® Purchase Contract Address Commissions?

The Hawaiʻi Association of REALTORS® (HAR) Purchase Contract includes provisions that allow the parties to address seller-paid buyer-broker compensation as part of the purchase negotiations.

For example:

A buyer finds a home listed for $500,000. The buyer has already signed a Buyer Representation Agreement specifying compensation of 2.5% of the purchase price. When the buyer submits an offer, the Purchase Contract can include a request for the seller to pay that 2.5% buyer-broker compensation at closing. The seller can accept the request, reject it, or negotiate different terms.

This means the seller is not automatically obligated to pay the buyer’s Realtor simply because the buyer has signed a representation agreement. The buyer’s brokerage also cannot simply increase its compensation beyond the amount specified in the Buyer Representation Agreement because a seller is willing to pay more.

buyer representation in hawaii

What Happens if the Seller Will Not Pay the Buyer’s Realtor?

Suppose the buyer has agreed to pay their brokerage 2.5%, but the seller declines to contribute toward that amount. Depending on the terms of the Buyer Representation Agreement, the buyer may be responsible for the difference or the entire agreed compensation. Alternatively, the buyer and their brokerage may negotiate an amendment to their agreement, if mutually acceptable and permitted by applicable rules. This is why it is so important for buyers to understand their agreement before signing. A knowledgeable Realtor should explain these provisions clearly, particularly when buyers are financing their purchase and may have limited funds available for closing costs.

Does the New System Mean Buyers Must Pay More?

Not necessarily. Sellers may still agree to pay the buyer’s brokerage compensation, just as they frequently did before August 2024. The difference is that compensation is now more explicitly addressed through written agreements and transaction negotiations rather than being advertised as an offer of compensation through the MLS. Buyers and sellers should also understand that commissions are not fixed by law and that each transaction may involve different compensation arrangements.

Why Working With an Experienced Buyer’s Realtor Still Matters

Purchasing real estate in Hawaiʻi can be considerably more complicated than buying property in many other parts of the country.

Here on the Big Island, buyers must consider issues such as lava hazard zones, financing restrictions, catchment water systems, septic systems, unpermitted structures, property boundaries, insurance availability, and much more. An experienced buyer’s Realtor can help with property research, market analysis, negotiating purchase terms, coordinating inspections, understanding contractual deadlines, and navigating the escrow process. The Buyer Representation Agreement provides a written understanding of the services being offered and the compensation involved.

My Final Thoughts

The real estate industry has undergone plenty of changes since August 2024, and it is understandable that some buyers and sellers remain confused about the new requirements.

The most important things to remember are:

  • Written buyer agreements are now required before an MLS-participating Realtor tours homes with a buyer.
  • Real estate commissions are negotiable and are not set by law.
  • A Buyer Representation Agreement establishes the buyer’s brokerage compensation.
  • The HAR Purchase Contract can be used to negotiate whether the seller will pay some or all of that compensation.
  • Sellers are not automatically required to pay buyer-broker commissions.
  • Buyers should understand any potential financial obligation before signing their representation agreement.

As a licensed Realtor on the Big Island since 2003, I believe that clear communication, transparency, and a thorough understanding of the real estate process are essential to a successful transaction. Whether you’re purchasing your first home, relocating to Hawaiʻi, or selling a property, I’m always happy to explain the process and help you navigate the ever-changing real estate market.

About the Author

Lisa R Heaviside

Lisa R Heaviside is a REALTOR Salesperson with Hawai'i Life. With over 20 years of experience as a licensed Realtor on the Big Island of Hawaii, I offer in-depth knowledge of the Big Island real estate market and a genuine passion for helping clients succeed. Having lived in several districts of the island, including Hamakua, North Kohala, North Kona and Puna, I bring firsthand insight in to the unique communities, climates and lifestyles that make each area special. Outside of real estate, I fully embrace the Big Island lifestyle. Whether I,m kayaking, swimming, snorkeling or fishing, my connection to this island deepens my appreciation for the place I call home and for the properties I represent. Throughout my career, I,ve developed strong negotiation skills and results-driven approach, always focused on protecting my client's best interests and maximizing value. I believe real estate is built on trust, clear communication and long lasting relationships. When you choose to work with me you can expect experienced guidance, honest advice and attentive service from start to finish. If you are considering selling your Big Island property or are searching for you next home, I would be honored to assist you. You can email me at lisaheaviside@hawaiilife.com or via phone at (808) 987-3791.

Comments (0) Show CommentsHide Comments (Remember)

Cool. Add your comment...

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Leave your opinion here. Please be nice. Your Email address will be kept private, this form is secure and we never spam you.

More Articles from Hawaii Life